What’s Actually Closing in 85936 Right Now
Closed transactions tell a clearer story than list-price averages. Five recent sales pulled from Redfin’s St. Johns feed show the spread:
| Property | Sale price | Days on market | Sale date |
|---|---|---|---|
| Octagon house, 2 bed / 2 bath, 2,004 sq ft | $269,900 | 417 | Apr 2, 2026 |
| 45 acres, Carrizo Ranch | $13,900 | 357 | Mar 16, 2026 |
| 38 acres, Woodland Valley Ranch | $19,900 | 317 | Mar 30, 2026 |
| Vacant lot, Denver Subdivision | $17,000 | 13 | Mar 6, 2026 |
| Rural parcel, County Rd N7421 | $75,000 (list $80,000) | 149 | Mar 5, 2026 |
Four of the five most recent closings are unimproved land, not houses, and land parcels here can sell in 13 days or sit for a year depending almost entirely on price versus what the parcel offers: road access, power proximity, acreage. A buyer comparing “median price in 85936” against a specific finished house is comparing that house to a number built mostly from land sales.
Is 85936 a buyer’s or seller’s market right now? Months of supply above 7 puts the zip in buyer territory as of June 2026, and price cuts of $10,000 to $25,000 on motivated listings are common past the 90-day mark, per the Arizona Homes and Condos report. Updated, in-city homes on grid utilities are the exception: those still move in 30 to 45 days.
Why Days-on-Market Numbers for This Zip Code Disagree
Five sources checked for this page reported five different days-on-market figures for the same zip code in the same general period: 188 days (Movoto’s zip page, June 2026), 202 days (Movoto’s city page, February 2026), 246 days (Movoto’s land page, May 2026), 68 days (Homes.com, trailing 12 months), and 65 days, up from 59 the prior month (Arizona Homes and Condos, June 2026). None of these figures is wrong on its own terms; they measure different populations.
Why do median price figures for this zip code vary so much between sites? Because median price here can mean median list price or median closed price, and it can include or exclude land parcels, and each portal picks a different combination without stating which. Ask any figure you’re given which of those two variables it’s measuring before comparing it across sites.
Rural Due Diligence Before You Write an Offer
A large share of 85936 inventory sits outside city limits in rural subdivisions like Witch Well Ranches, Sierra Highlands Ranch, and River Springs Ranch, most with no HOA and no guaranteed grid utilities. Four checks apply before an offer on anything outside the incorporated city:
| Item | Why it matters | Who verifies it |
|---|---|---|
| Zoning designation | A-G (Agricultural General) is the default zoning Apache County applies to any parcel not otherwise zoned; confirm before planning non-agricultural use | Apache County Zoning Ordinance, §202, §305 |
| Septic eligibility | Individual septic disposal requires a minimum 1-acre lot; smaller lots need a common sewerage system approved by the state | Apache County Subdivision Ordinance |
| Road maintenance | Some rural roads are county-maintained, others private; one active listing near River Springs Ranch specifies county-maintained access, but this varies parcel by parcel | Apache County Engineer’s Office |
| Power and utility hookup | Many rural parcels run on solar, generator, or shared well rather than a grid connection | Local utility provider; seller disclosure |
One active listing illustrates the pattern directly: a 37.25-acre parcel in the River Springs Ranch unit, marketed on its Lyman Lake views and county-maintained access off County Road 6040, sits roughly 8 miles from town with a power pole nearby but no confirmed grid connection to the lot itself.
Can I get a conventional mortgage on unimproved land here? No county or lender source publishes financing terms specific to raw acreage in 85936, and this page won’t guess at loan-to-value or down-payment numbers no one has published. Confirm directly with a local lender before assuming conventional, appraisal-based financing applies; comparable recent sales of similar unimproved parcels, which conventional appraisals rely on, are the land rows in the table above and not much else.
What Property Tax Runs in Apache County
Apache County carries the lowest median effective property tax rate in Arizona at 0.45%, below the statewide median of 0.51% and well under the national median of 1.02%, per Ownwell’s Apache County data.
| Jurisdiction | Median effective property tax rate |
|---|---|
| Apache County | 0.45% |
| Arizona (statewide median) | 0.51% |
| Cochise County (highest in Arizona) | 0.87% |
| United States (national median) | 1.02% |
At that rate, a $220,000 purchase carries a substantially lighter annual tax load here than the same price would in most of the country; Ownwell’s statewide figures put Arizona’s median bill at $1,695 against a national median of $2,400, and Apache County sits below even that state figure.
Population and the One Real Demand Driver
St. Johns held roughly 3,395 residents as of the 2024 American Community Survey estimates, a population change of about −2.9% since 2019, per Census Reporter. The town’s steadiest non-local demand pull is Lyman Lake State Park, an 11-mile drive south on US-180/191, whose 1,500-acre reservoir is one of the few bodies of water in Arizona with no boat-size restriction. Land within reach of the lake carries a visible listing premium over comparable acreage elsewhere in the zip.
Is St. Johns real estate a good long-term hold given the population trend? A shrinking or flat population base argues against betting on organic growth to drive appreciation. Any investment thesis here needs to rest on land use, recreation proximity, or price rather than expected local population gains.
Leave a Reply